Welcome! These forums will be deactivated by the end of this year. The conversation continues in a new morph over on Discord! Please join us there for a more active conversation and the occasional opportunity to ask developers questions directly! Go to the PS+ Discord Server.

Firewall Logo?

57 posts / 0 new
Last post
The Mad Ruster The Mad Ruster's picture
Firewall Logo?
Are there any Firewall logos floating around out there?

I don't belong as no one owns.

Decivre Decivre's picture
I doubt it. It's generally
I doubt it. It's generally bad form for a secretive organization to use an identifying logo. Why do you think so many people know who the Freemasons are?
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Admini Admini's picture
Masons aren't really a

Masons aren't really a secret group, just a group with secrets. Or so they ell me.
jackgraham jackgraham's picture
In my campaign, it's a
In my campaign, it's a unicorn pegasus with butterfly wings rampant on a field sable. Which is why it's a good thing that my more level-headed friends are the devs. ;)
J A C K   G R A H A M :: Hooray for Earth!   http://eclipsephase.com :: twitter @jackgraham @faketsr :: Google+Jack Graham
JLongden JLongden's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
Admini wrote:
Masons aren't really a secret group, just a group with secrets. Or so they ell me.
... and most of their secrets aren't particularly secret.
[Size=2]"The great thing about the internet is its leveling effect; online all opinions are equally WORTHLESS."-- Grant Morrison[/size]
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
JLongden wrote:
Admini wrote:
Masons aren't really a secret group, just a group with secrets. Or so they ell me.
... and most of their secrets aren't particularly secret.
Exactly. Firewall is an actual secret organization... the kind I can't give a good example of, because all the good examples are secrets.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
OneTrikPony OneTrikPony's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
:( We're still gonna have a secret handshake, Right?

Mea Culpa: My mode of speech can make others feel uninvited to argue or participate. This is the EXACT opposite of what I intend when I post.

Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
OneTrikPony wrote:
:( We're still gonna have a secret handshake, Right?
Yes, but no one is allowed to know what it is. You know... to maintain the secrecy of it. :D
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
The Doctor The Doctor's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
It probably would involve Diffie-Hellman and a pseudo-random number generator. ;)
OneTrikPony OneTrikPony's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
DAMIT! I knever know the secret handshake :( Can I get a hint? C'mon guys, Please? (stupid rep score) [walks away kicking rocks]

Mea Culpa: My mode of speech can make others feel uninvited to argue or participate. This is the EXACT opposite of what I intend when I post.

The Doctor The Doctor's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
15f9dbeac4f2f48278d22c9fe41c0519 ;)
OneTrikPony OneTrikPony's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
OK. now you're just making stuff up! That's not fair. LOL

Mea Culpa: My mode of speech can make others feel uninvited to argue or participate. This is the EXACT opposite of what I intend when I post.

Cardul Cardul's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
OneTrikPony wrote:
OK. now you're just making stuff up! That's not fair. LOL
Well, you know...I think everyone is "just making stuff up." The developers, though, get paid for it ;) Also, how do you know that that is not the secret handshake? Sure, it is not a physical contact greeting, but it could easily be the "handshake protocol" of their Mesh interfaces...
standard_gravity standard_gravity's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
Don't underestimate the power of the good ol' wink-wink nudge nudge :)
[img]http://boxall.no-ip.org/img/ext_userbar.jpg[/img] "People think dreams aren't real just because they aren't made of matter, of particles. Dreams are real. But they are made of viewpoints, of images, of memories and puns and lost hopes." - John Dee
The Doctor The Doctor's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
That is how webs of trust are formed, after all. :)
TheRawrnstuff TheRawrnstuff's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
Decivre wrote:
...because all the good examples are secrets.
How about Beati Paoli?
thefnord thefnord's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
OneTrikPony wrote:
:( We're still gonna have a secret handshake, Right?
I hear Octomorphs have the best ones. I'm so working that into an Europa-centric plot.

Lorem ipsum dolore sit amet, motherfucker.

It that must no... It that must not be named's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Heh heh, all this talk about symbols and secret organizations made me think of an old joke which I shall recycle for EP: The head of the Jovian Republic called the most well known tailor in the jupter system into his office and asked him to design a uniform meant to strike terror into the hearts of the republic's enemies. After some time, the tailor came up with an outfit featuring a bright crimson tunic adorned with a death's head logo on the chest and sword icons on the sleeves, pants with black and yellow hazard striping running down the thighs and knee high glossly black boots. The whole thing was topped off with a red beret with a "Death the frankfreaks!" logo on it. The junta official was delighted with it and the tailor said "I'm sure your special forces will look intimidating in this." The official said "Special forces? No, this is for the secret police!"

"I learned the hard way that if you take a stand on any issue, no matter how insignificant, people will line up around the block to kick your ass over it." -Jesse "the mind" Ventura.

The Doctor The Doctor's picture
Re: Masons aren't really a
Hmmm... when you take into account the fact that each sucker on an octopus' tentacle can swivel into a different position to get a better grasp, that really would be a secret handshake. "Hey, wait a minute! Your suckers are not all turning anticlockwise! Imposter!"
Iv Iv's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
My logo is the silhouette of a meditating human encircled by a wall of fire. On the chest of the human is an opened eye. I don't think it is mentionned anywhere but it seemed logical for me to provide all sentinels with Firewall cryptographic keys. Meaning that when they receive these messages, they know only a sentinel can have generated it and only a Firewall member can read it. For now, the 'secret handshake' my players are learning involves exchanging a few bursts of ammunition before trying to talk.
The Doctor The Doctor's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Iv wrote:
My logo is the silhouette of a meditating human encircled by a wall of fire. On the chest of the human is an opened eye.
Very [url=http://rantmedia.ca/graphics-essentials.php]Rant Media[/url]. I like it.
Iv wrote:
I don't think it is mentionned anywhere but it seemed logical for me to provide all sentinels with Firewall cryptographic keys. Meaning that when they receive these messages, they know only a sentinel can have generated it and only a Firewall member can read it.
That seems reasonable. Firewall would have its own web of trust for PKE (or whatever succeeded it during the Fall), plus to access their virtual networks they would have to supply credentials and authentication tokens.
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
I also assume that any Firewall member is given a set of cryptographic keys that allows them to authenticate their messages, check that a message really is from firewall and even send some emergency ultra-secure messages using one-time pads. They also get a database of codewords, codesigns and other signals that can be used to indicate "firewall". These are like watermarking: if you (or your muse) are not looking for these signs they will not look out of the place - someone wearing a paisley shirt, talking about fishing and using the word "obnoxious" as the third word of a sentence is not very suspicious. Unless you happen to know that these three signals are in the database. Each sign increases the likeliehood that this is a firewall agent. The fun thing is that you can randomly select elements from the database, different people may have partially overlapping databases and one can update them over time (after all, once a sign is used it should not be reused). In my intro adventure I had a simspace meeting happening inside a hacked art-game in the mesh. They used the signs database to find the hacked area where they could slip into the Firewall system.
Extropian
Stormseed Stormseed's picture
Re: I doubt it. It's generally
Cerberus from Mass Effect has a logo. It does seem to be fairly well known in certain circles, tho. Firewall's (possible) logo would probably be similarly abstract.
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
I just found this blog post about the logos of terrorist organizations: http://www.ironicsans.com/2007/07/terrorist_organization_logos.html Just because you are secret and illegal doesn't mean you can't have a logo. Whether it is nicely designed is another matter...
Extropian
Bloodwork Bloodwork's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
That which doesn't kill you usually succeeds on the second attempt.
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Arenamontanus wrote:
I just found this blog post about the logos of terrorist organizations: http://www.ironicsans.com/2007/07/terrorist_organization_logos.html Just because you are secret and illegal doesn't mean you can't have a logo. Whether it is nicely designed is another matter...
Terrorist groups generally aren't very secretive. They go public to make their agenda known (which is how they give their terrorist actions "meaning"). Firewall does not. No one in the EP universe, outside of its members and enemies, know about Firewall.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Psyfer Psyfer's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
I thought it was the funny little flower thingy at the end of the'in-game' sidebar messages in the corebook.....
Just another Ghost in the Machine...
Meldaran Meldaran's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Looks like that Celio clothing logo ;) Mel.
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Psyfer wrote:
I thought it was the funny little flower thingy at the end of the'in-game' sidebar messages in the corebook.....
I think that's an asterisk. Then again, an asterisk might be their logo, if they have one.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
nick012000 nick012000's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Decivre wrote:
Psyfer wrote:
I thought it was the funny little flower thingy at the end of the'in-game' sidebar messages in the corebook.....
I think that's an asterisk. Then again, an asterisk might be their logo, if they have one.
I don't think it's an asterisk; asterisks have six arms, and that symbol only has five. I think it might be some sort of five-petalled flower. It also shows up behind the authentication symbols in the sidebars, so I think it might well be their logo.

+1 r-Rep , +1 @-rep

Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
nick012000 wrote:
I don't think it's an asterisk; asterisks have six arms, and that symbol only has five. I think it might be some sort of five-petalled flower. It also shows up behind the authentication symbols in the sidebars, so I think it might well be their logo.
Depends on the font and typeset. The asterisk has five points as shown on my keyboard. The same with the asterisk in the Lucida Console font that I usually use. Every font in the Hack Pack except Liberation Serif has a five-point asterisk. The only real difference is the inversion of the one used in the book, which can be easily done. I'm not saying it isn't a logo, but it may just as well be a stylistic element.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
TheWanderingJewels TheWanderingJewels's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
a possible phrase: quisnam vigilo "Who Watches"
A brave little theory, and actually quite coherent for a system of five or seven dimensions--if only we lived in one. Academician Prokhor Zakharov "Now We Are Alone"
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
TheWanderingJewels wrote:
a possible phrase: quisnam vigilo "Who Watches"
If they were going to have some awesome latin phrase as part of their logo, it would be a latin translation of "There cannot be another Fall".
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
TheWanderingJewels TheWanderingJewels's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
While true: TITANS would have access to Latin from uploads and who knows what the little creeps let behind to obsrve and learn. I picked the above phrase as not quiet so obvious. But for the record in rough latin: Illic cannot exsisto alius Cado = There cannot be another Fall
A brave little theory, and actually quite coherent for a system of five or seven dimensions--if only we lived in one. Academician Prokhor Zakharov "Now We Are Alone"
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
TheWanderingJewels wrote:
While true: TITANS would have access to Latin from uploads and who knows what the little creeps let behind to obsrve and learn. I picked the above phrase as not quiet so obvious. But for the record in rough latin: Illic cannot exsisto alius Cado = There cannot be another Fall
Actually, I think a more appropriate translation would be "Illic can non exsisto alius Cado". Cannot is a contracted English word, so I suspect that it had no direct translation to Latin. By separating it, I think I found a more accurate phrasing. On the other hand, perhaps "Illic mos non exsisto alius Cado" will be more accurate, since I do not know if the word "can" has a direct Latin translation, and it is not rooted in Latin. This translates to "There will not be another Fall".
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
TheWanderingJewels TheWanderingJewels's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
I thought that might work a bit better. I was also going for the secret society style catch phrase that is indistinct until you are inducted and made to understand what it means
A brave little theory, and actually quite coherent for a system of five or seven dimensions--if only we lived in one. Academician Prokhor Zakharov "Now We Are Alone"
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
TheWanderingJewels wrote:
I thought that might work a bit better. I was also going for the secret society style catch phrase that is indistinct until you are inducted and made to understand what it means
Yeah, they might do that. Granted I think that "There cannot be another Fall" is probably a common sentiment amongst transhumankind during the time period of Eclipse Phase. But it does make me wonder how common Latin really is in the universe after the Fall. There were many languages lost in the aftermath, and Latin wasn't too big to begin with (unless you count scientists who used it to label crap).
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
TheWanderingJewels TheWanderingJewels's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
A fair point. But considering that the TITANS absorbed all worldly databases before they did the big fade, I can only assume they have translation software for Latin somewhere
A brave little theory, and actually quite coherent for a system of five or seven dimensions--if only we lived in one. Academician Prokhor Zakharov "Now We Are Alone"
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
TheWanderingJewels wrote:
A fair point. But considering that the TITANS absorbed all worldly databases before they did the big fade, I can only assume they have translation software for Latin somewhere
Not necessarily. They likely only absorbed any information they needed. Unless the TITANs intended to communicate with us, what purpose would they have with learning the language? Hell, the real question is whether they even consider us a threat... I don't really keep watch for secret attempts on my life by various ant colonies, so why would a super-intelligence even think of spying on us for any real purpose? If they want us dead, they could probably do it without problem, no real need for intelligence-gathering.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Good Latin mottos tend to be rather compressed. My Latin is extremely rusty, but I think a more proper motto would be "Cadem alius nolemus " - we do not want/we refuse another fall (Yes, it is close to "Fall: do not want!" :-) ). Another version would be a gerundive construction: "Cadem alius non permittendi" (I'm a bit uncertain whether it should be in the accusative case - as I said, my skills are rusty). As for Latin, it is a very dead language even today: there are no native speakers (and most scientists today do not know it, sadly). But dead languages have their followers, and I doubt knowledge of Latin would have been lost in the Fall (too many out-of-copyright textbooks around). In fact, with hyperlinguistics it is not too unlikely that many would have learned it just as a hobby. As a secret language it doesn't work, but for an inspirational old-fashioned motto reminding about our duties, it works. Arenamontanus de Collum Caeruleus
Extropian
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Arenamontanus wrote:
Good Latin mottos tend to be rather compressed. My Latin is extremely rusty, but I think a more proper motto would be "Cadem alius nolemus " - we do not want/we refuse another fall (Yes, it is close to "Fall: do not want!" :-) ). Another version would be a gerundive construction: "Cadem alius non permittendi" (I'm a bit uncertain whether it should be in the accusative case - as I said, my skills are rusty). As for Latin, it is a very dead language even today: there are no native speakers (and most scientists today do not know it, sadly). But dead languages have their followers, and I doubt knowledge of Latin would have been lost in the Fall (too many out-of-copyright textbooks around). In fact, with hyperlinguistics it is not too unlikely that many would have learned it just as a hobby. As a secret language it doesn't work, but for an inspirational old-fashioned motto reminding about our duties, it works. Arenamontanus de Collum Caeruleus
The main reason I think it likely to be dead is because of the scarcity of it today. The primary speakers of the language are largely within the Roman Catholic church, and the largest source of its documentation is contained within its library. Considering how greatly the church's losses during the Fall were, I think that the amount of material remaining is minimal at best. We do know that there are many dead languages as a result of the Fall. Considering that there is documentation in almost every language with little exception, I'd imagine that every language would have theoretically survived if that was all that was needed to continue to exist. Unfortunately it is worse than that. I'd imagine that Latin, along with many of my other favorite languages (Tagalog, most if not all Ryukyuan languages, Esperanto) will likely no longer exist... at least without a few salvage trips to Earth, of course.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
standard_gravity standard_gravity's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Decivre wrote:
I'd imagine that Latin /.../ will likely no longer exist... at least without a few salvage trips to Earth, of course.
So Firewall sends a team to Earth to figure out if their motto really makes sense (after having been made to think otherwise in a satirical note with suspected Project Ozma origins). Adventure hook right there. ;)
[img]http://boxall.no-ip.org/img/ext_userbar.jpg[/img] "People think dreams aren't real just because they aren't made of matter, of particles. Dreams are real. But they are made of viewpoints, of images, of memories and puns and lost hopes." - John Dee
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
standard_gravity wrote:
So Firewall sends a team to Earth to figure out if their motto really makes sense (after having been made to think otherwise in a satirical note with suspected Project Ozma origins). Adventure hook right there. ;)
Wow, I think it would be hilarious if they sent dozens of sentinels to their deaths at the hands of TITAN war machines, only to get that much back. I wonder what else they might do that for. "Sir, we got it. Most of us died, but we got it!" "Perfect, I've always wanted to try a Cuban cigar!" "Sir? I... I thought you said it was of the greatest importance! I watched my best friend have his head torn off and flown away, so you could have a smoke?!?!" "Okay, first off, I said it was one of the greatest [b]imports[/b]. And yes... yes you did...."
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Decivre wrote:
The main reason I think it likely to be dead is because of the scarcity of it today. The primary speakers of the language are largely within the Roman Catholic church, and the largest source of its documentation is contained within its library. Considering how greatly the church's losses during the Fall were, I think that the amount of material remaining is minimal at best.
Hahahaha! Sorry, but this is extremely unlikely. While natural scientists these days do not learn Latin, there is plenty of it around from the old days - think about the binomial system of species names. Humanist scholars - classicists, linguists, historians of all kinds - do use it *actively* in their research, and there are plenty of online databases containing primary texts, as well as widely forked text databases. It would only take that one Fall survivor happened to have a copy of Project Gutenberg on their iphone++ and an enormous amount of source material would have survived. And if there were a linguist among the survivors, they are likely to have carried with them an enormous text corpus if they were anything like the linguists I know. While I can believe enormous losses of data in the Fall I have a hard time imagining widely distributed knowledge such as Latin to be lost. Maybe a good Fall data loss model would be that 99% of all copies of everything disappeared. That means that there is a 99% chance that a single document disappeared. If there were ten copies, there is a 90% chance that all have been lost. If there were a hundred copies, 36% chance. A thousand, just 0.0043% chance! As a good rule of thumb then, if you can get more than a thousand hits on something on google or in libraries worldwide, then it has definitely survived. (In practice, even many single hits actually exist in multiple datacenters) A dead language is not an incomprehensible language. Sanskrit, old church slavonic, avestan and ge'ez are still used for religious purposes (and consequently have plenty of material of the type that somebody might deliberately try to save in a disaster) and can be understood. We have pretty good ideas of sumerian cuneiform and hieroglyphics. Proto-Indo-European is really extinct, but has been partially reconstructed (and some people even think they can find traces of the hypothetic Proto-Nostratic that preceded it). Reconstructing languages from limited corpora is hard (Linear A & B, anyone?), but a language like Latin is extremely close to current languages. Even if we had lost it, an interested post-Fall linguist would have been able to reconstruct it rapidly. Of course, having some linguists crow that they have saved tagalog or klingon doesn't mean anybody speaks them.
Extropian
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Arenamontanus wrote:
Hahahaha! Sorry, but this is extremely unlikely. While natural scientists these days do not learn Latin, there is plenty of it around from the old days - think about the binomial system of species names. Humanist scholars - classicists, linguists, historians of all kinds - do use it *actively* in their research, and there are plenty of online databases containing primary texts, as well as widely forked text databases. It would only take that one Fall survivor happened to have a copy of Project Gutenberg on their iphone++ and an enormous amount of source material would have survived. And if there were a linguist among the survivors, they are likely to have carried with them an enormous text corpus if they were anything like the linguists I know. While I can believe enormous losses of data in the Fall I have a hard time imagining widely distributed knowledge such as Latin to be lost. Maybe a good Fall data loss model would be that 99% of all copies of everything disappeared. That means that there is a 99% chance that a single document disappeared. If there were ten copies, there is a 90% chance that all have been lost. If there were a hundred copies, 36% chance. A thousand, just 0.0043% chance! As a good rule of thumb then, if you can get more than a thousand hits on something on google or in libraries worldwide, then it has definitely survived. (In practice, even many single hits actually exist in multiple datacenters) A dead language is not an incomprehensible language. Sanskrit, old church slavonic, avestan and ge'ez are still used for religious purposes (and consequently have plenty of material of the type that somebody might deliberately try to save in a disaster) and can be understood. We have pretty good ideas of sumerian cuneiform and hieroglyphics. Proto-Indo-European is really extinct, but has been partially reconstructed (and some people even think they can find traces of the hypothetic Proto-Nostratic that preceded it). Reconstructing languages from limited corpora is hard (Linear A & B, anyone?), but a language like Latin is extremely close to current languages. Even if we had lost it, an interested post-Fall linguist would have been able to reconstruct it rapidly. Of course, having some linguists crow that they have saved tagalog or klingon doesn't mean anybody speaks them.
Remember that the number of people who escaped Earth with [i]even their body[/i] is extremely rare. Even knick knacks from Earth are worth huge amounts of money. It may very well be possible that such things from Earth never made it off. Of the almost half-billion that now live in the system, around 400 million of them are now either infomorph refugees or members of the clanking masses. That doesn't leave too many of them with their original bodies, let alone treasures from the Earthen surface. Admittedly, it's very possible that someone did escape with such data, but it is definitely not a guaranteed thing. But again, it's likely to be retrievable knowledge. Much of our collected human knowledge is just sitting there on Earth, waiting to be found. It's very likely that every language we lost in the Fall could very easily be gained again, with a little luck and searching. It may have even already been retrieved, a brave Catholic bioconservative going on a bold adventure to Earth to get pieces of his religious identity from the surface.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Decivre wrote:
Remember that the number of people who escaped Earth with [i]even their body[/i] is extremely rare. Even knick knacks from Earth are worth huge amounts of money. It may very well be possible that such things from Earth never made it off.
"We were so busy escaping the fire we didn't remember to save the clothes we were wearing". Physical knick knacks are hard to save, but informational ones are easy. An egocast is at least on the order of many terabytes in size, and it seems unlikely that people can't bring with them many gigabytes of their informational possessions. As well as their skills: you can always make skillsofts out of people's languages. There are a few thousand people who can *speak* latin today, so we should expect (given my earlier probability estimate) that several of them survived. The number of latin *readers* at the very least is on the order of hundreds of thousands, likely many more. Hence the likelihood of all of them having bad luck in the Fall is essentially zero. The law of large numbers makes this an almost guaranteed thing. Given the development in EP orbital data centres seem entirely plausible, which means that there were likely many off-site backups of many databases. A site like Wikipedia (which, by the way, has 10,000 articles written in the language) needs several server clusters, especially to keep interplanetary lags down. Note that this does not mean I am claiming that nothing was lost; on the contrary, you only know when some piece of information is crucial when you suddenly can't find it. The three people who knew the root password for the Wikipedia server got eaten by the TITANs. Nobody had paid for an orbital copy of Project Perseus, so all source material is now from Project Gutenberg. A convention of Sanskrit experts was going on in Chicago when it got nuked; no surviving linguist is an expert on the language. The egocast content filters removed all of Catullus' poems.
Extropian
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Arenamontanus wrote:
"We were so busy escaping the fire we didn't remember to save the clothes we were wearing". Physical knick knacks are hard to save, but informational ones are easy. An egocast is at least on the order of many terabytes in size, and it seems unlikely that people can't bring with them many gigabytes of their informational possessions. As well as their skills: you can always make skillsofts out of people's languages. There are a few thousand people who can *speak* latin today, so we should expect (given my earlier probability estimate) that several of them survived. The number of latin *readers* at the very least is on the order of hundreds of thousands, likely many more. Hence the likelihood of all of them having bad luck in the Fall is essentially zero. The law of large numbers makes this an almost guaranteed thing. Given the development in EP orbital data centres seem entirely plausible, which means that there were likely many off-site backups of many databases. A site like Wikipedia (which, by the way, has 10,000 articles written in the language) needs several server clusters, especially to keep interplanetary lags down. Note that this does not mean I am claiming that nothing was lost; on the contrary, you only know when some piece of information is crucial when you suddenly can't find it. The three people who knew the root password for the Wikipedia server got eaten by the TITANs. Nobody had paid for an orbital copy of Project Perseus, so all source material is now from Project Gutenberg. A convention of Sanskrit experts was going on in Chicago when it got nuked; no surviving linguist is an expert on the language. The egocast content filters removed all of Catullus' poems.
Then I think it difficult to believe that virtually any language was really lost in the fall. The only languages that could have possibly been lost were those passed on by oral tradition, and even those might have been XP recorded at some point, and archived. So long as there is archived documentation of any language, it can be recovered. Perhaps what they mean by "lost languages" in the book is that there are some languages for which there are no more speakers or even readers. Other than the occasional hobbyist, perhaps no one has taken the time to learn some of the languages that now simply exist in data form.
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Decivre wrote:
Perhaps what they mean by "lost languages" in the book is that there are some languages for which there are no more speakers or even readers. Other than the occasional hobbyist, perhaps no one has taken the time to learn some of the languages that now simply exist in data form.
I think that is true. There are at least some uses for Latin, but if you learn Dalmatian or Kumbainggar you have nobody to talk to and not much to read. A lot of pre-Fall information is simply stored away and not used. Even knowing it is there may disappear if there are no obvious uses for it. If there is no traditional agriculture anywhere, then those skills and knowledge will tend to decay. Numismatics might survive due to hobbyists (but have very few real coins left), but a philosophical school that was out of fashion during the fall is completely dead.
Extropian
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Arenamontanus wrote:
I think that is true. There are at least some uses for Latin, but if you learn Dalmatian or Kumbainggar you have nobody to talk to and not much to read. A lot of pre-Fall information is simply stored away and not used. Even knowing it is there may disappear if there are no obvious uses for it. If there is no traditional agriculture anywhere, then those skills and knowledge will tend to decay. Numismatics might survive due to hobbyists (but have very few real coins left), but a philosophical school that was out of fashion during the fall is completely dead.
I don't know. The only major things we use Latin for today are scientific nomenclature, loanwords (for which we use many languages) and styled inscriptions. While many western nations use Latin inscriptions today, EP no longer has western nations... and it is very possible that most people who identify as having originated from a western nation may either use a different language from Latin (Japanese and Chinese have both begun to take hold as an "exotic language" to people nowadays, often used in tattoos and designs) or simply use their native tongue for such slogans. In the realm of taxonomy, recent discoveries are often simply given English names... most discoveries since the 70s have either an English name (Human immunodeficiency virus is both the name and species nomenclature for the virus), or one that is only nominally Latin (H. Floresiensis is has a Latin suffix attached to the Portuguese name of an island). It's very possible that down the line, nomenclature will be more commonly done in another language (very possibly English), since it is also more commonly known by the whole of the scientific community. Besides, much of taxonomy will be rendered useless after the fall. All of the taxonomic information we have on the species of Earth would only be useful for historical purposes, because most species will have been rendered extinct. Even the fields of paleontology and archeology will be understudied on account of the fact that we simply cannot go to Earth to do research. On account of the fall, it's very possible that many fields of science will be converted to historical endeavors, because further research is simply not doable. That said, they will make room for newer fields of a similar kind (like xenoarcheology and xenopaleontology).
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Decivre wrote:
The only major things we use Latin for today are scientific nomenclature, loanwords (for which we use many languages) and styled inscriptions.
And research in the humanities - if you are doing anything related to pre-modern history or literature you better know Latin. And it is used in religious proclamations some billion people take seriously. Latin expressions also play a pretty common role in law, linguistics, practically all academic fields (except perhaps computer science...) A Roman would say we are not speaking Latin, and he would be right. But we are *using* Latin and it is definitely not forgotten.
Quote:
In the realm of taxonomy, recent discoveries are often simply given English names... most discoveries since the 70s have either an English name (Human immunodeficiency virus is both the name and species nomenclature for the virus), or one that is only nominally Latin (H. Floresiensis is has a Latin suffix attached to the Portuguese name of an island). It's very possible that down the line, nomenclature will be more commonly done in another language (very possibly English), since it is also more commonly known by the whole of the scientific community.
Floresiensis is the genitive form of the latinization of Flores, meaning "of Flores". It is just as Latin as the slime-mold beetle Agathidium rumsfeldi. And plenty of newly discovered species are pure Latin: Opisthostoma vermiculum, Chromis abyssus, Tahina spectablilis, Hippocampus satomiae... When it comes to HIV, virus nomenclature works differently (and messily) compared to cellular organism nomenclature. HIV is a Group VI (ssRNA-RT) virus in the retroviridae family, genus lentivirus. It can't get away from the Latin either. In the long run I think biologists will simply classify species using something derived from their genome, likely some form of fingerprint code. But I doubt anybody would use '#59743700013' to denote a house cat or '#0273183883' for Agathidium rumsfeldi in normal conversation or text beyond pointing out which species the discussion is about. When you breed beetles based on genomes found in online databases you won't call your shimmering creature '#0272226301-B', you will call it Lampropepla extropia.
Extropian
Decivre Decivre's picture
Re: Firewall Logo?
Arenamontanus wrote:
And research in the humanities - if you are doing anything related to pre-modern history or literature you better know Latin. And it is used in religious proclamations some billion people take seriously. Latin expressions also play a pretty common role in law, linguistics, practically all academic fields (except perhaps computer science...) A Roman would say we are not speaking Latin, and he would be right. But we are *using* Latin and it is definitely not forgotten.
Those religions took a massive hit in the Fall, so it's very possible that what remnants the Catholic/East Orthodox faith has do not know the language (especially since the total number of Latin speakers in either church make up less than 1% of all members). Humanities perhaps, but translation technologies have come a long way, and it may very well be possible to find most of those documents in any language you speak.
Arenamontanus wrote:
Floresiensis is the genitive form of the latinization of Flores, meaning "of Flores". It is just as Latin as the slime-mold beetle Agathidium rumsfeldi. And plenty of newly discovered species are pure Latin: Opisthostoma vermiculum, Chromis abyssus, Tahina spectablilis, Hippocampus satomiae... When it comes to HIV, virus nomenclature works differently (and messily) compared to cellular organism nomenclature. HIV is a Group VI (ssRNA-RT) virus in the retroviridae family, genus lentivirus. It can't get away from the Latin either. In the long run I think biologists will simply classify species using something derived from their genome, likely some form of fingerprint code. But I doubt anybody would use '#59743700013' to denote a house cat or '#0273183883' for Agathidium rumsfeldi in normal conversation or text beyond pointing out which species the discussion is about. When you breed beetles based on genomes found in online databases you won't call your shimmering creature '#0272226301-B', you will call it Lampropepla extropia.
Or you might call it the "Extropian jewel beetle", or some Japanese, Mandarin or Cantonese equivalent. I just don't see any feasible chance of extended survivability for the language should a cataclysmic event like the Fall occur. I mean I agree that it's not likely people would commonly refer to a housecat by their genome hash number, but in that same vein I highly doubt they'd refer to the rumsfeld beetle by its latin nomenclature. Most English speakers would have an easier time saying "rumsfeld beetle".
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]

Pages