Please forgive me if my question has been answered - I searched the forums and didn't come up with an answer, and perhaps I missed it in the book. Okay, I am making the assumption that a critical success or failure is dependent upon what is rolled on the dice, not by the result of a roll with modifiers applied; e.g. Monjay rolls a 56 and applies a +10 difficulty modifier, making the result a 66. This is not a critical fail. If I'm wrong, please do clarify! My queston, however, is about the circumstances in which a player rolls a critical success, and the modifiers make it a failure - does it become a critical failure? For example, Monjay rolls a 22 on his "post a relevant forum post," a critical success! However, once we apply the "+20 caffeine supply depleted" modifier, the result is a 42 and a failure. Does the critical nature turn it to a critical failure, or does it just ... ahem ... go away?