Welcome! These forums will be deactivated by the end of this year. The conversation continues in a new morph over on Discord! Please join us there for a more active conversation and the occasional opportunity to ask developers questions directly! Go to the PS+ Discord Server.

Resleeving to a flat

15 posts / 0 new
Last post
Esiminar Esiminar's picture
Resleeving to a flat
Having broken my iPad today, which has been a constant companion for the the past 3 1/2 years, I find myself feeling as if I have lost a limb. I keep reaching for the capabilities that it gave me and them not being there. This left me wondering how someone who had always had mesh inserts would feel resleeving into a morph lacking them and whether this would or should affect integration or alienation checks.
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
If your inserts are really a
If your inserts are really a part of your thinking this might make the experience really alien and traumatic. A few years ago I realized that I was unconsciously checking stuff on Wikipedia all the time. I was in China and couldn't get access - besides the annoyance and feeling of being limited, there was the scary moment when I realized that Wikipedia was essentially part of my normal thought processes. Not a huge part, but still an element in how I approach many questions. Now scale that up to having a Muse and instant access: I think most people have extended minds that do not enjoy suddenly being lobotomized. Flats also have plenty of other misfeatures: huge sleep requirements, lots of little pains, aches and quirks that normal morphs have fixed or rationalized away. I would say they are unsettling precisely because they are so close to a "real" body, yet differ - a kind of uncanny valley for a generation who has grown up since uploading.
Extropian
Decivre Decivre's picture
Arenamontanus wrote:If your
Arenamontanus wrote:
If your inserts are really a part of your thinking this might make the experience really alien and traumatic. A few years ago I realized that I was unconsciously checking stuff on Wikipedia all the time. I was in China and couldn't get access - besides the annoyance and feeling of being limited, there was the scary moment when I realized that Wikipedia was essentially part of my normal thought processes. Not a huge part, but still an element in how I approach many questions. Now scale that up to having a Muse and instant access: I think most people have extended minds that do not enjoy suddenly being lobotomized. Flats also have plenty of other misfeatures: huge sleep requirements, lots of little pains, aches and quirks that normal morphs have fixed or rationalized away. I would say they are unsettling precisely because they are so close to a "real" body, yet differ - a kind of uncanny valley for a generation who has grown up since uploading.
I've noticed this trend too. My first reaction to hearing a new fact or piece of information is to surf a search engine (usually Google or DuckDuckGo) and see if I can find secondary confirmation. I've also noticed that it is almost autonomic... the second information passes my ears, I'm looking for my nearest portal to the internet just for fact-checking. I can only imagine how much more this though-process will be magnified when I have constant access to a thought-controlled internet-enabled device. Even now, I get twitchy when I don't have the means to check my email, search for something on my mind, or even check forums. After such a shift, the loss of those abilities would be tantamount to losing limbs. Even going back to the old way of doing things would probably be hard... how many of us would handle losing graphic user interfaces and going back to the days of command line everything? Now extrapolate that feeling to how you might react to losing thought control and having to go back to these archaic keyboards and mice. One day, having to use a cell phone for anything might be the average person's idea of "roughing it".
Transhumans will one day be the Luddites of the posthuman age. [url=http://bit.ly/2p3wk7c]Help me get my gaming fix, if you want.[/url]
Arenamontanus Arenamontanus's picture
In philosophy there is an
In philosophy there is an idea called the "extended mind hypothesis" that claims that if external tools does processing for a person that we would call 'mental' if it occurred inside a mind, they should also be regarded as part of the person's mind. The classic example is a person using a notebook as an external memory aid: were he to lose it, the hypothesis argues that he would really lose some memory for real. Now in EP, people have extended minds that are really extended. The mesh inserts are part of them, as is likely the Muse and plenty of other more obvious software routines - as well as normally invisible systems maintaining their body image mapping to the morph (stuff like making synthmorphs feel normal despite not breathing, or handling the really strange shape of a swarmanoid). But beyond that there is the whole Mesh. Most people do not update reps consciously: the rep networks are to some extent part of shared cognition. In fact, transhumans likely have so extended cognition that merely becoming a zero would affect their mental stability a lot.
Extropian
Prophet710 Prophet710's picture
I can only imagine what it
I can only imagine what it would feel like beyond the mesh inserts. Cerebral implants, reflex boosters, muscle augmentation, suddenly all of these are gone. I can only think it would be a bit like waking up hungover after a month long drinking binge with very little to eat.
"And yet, across the gulf of space, minds immeasurably superior to ours regarded this Earth with envious eyes. And slowly, and surely, they drew their plans against us."
bibliophile20 bibliophile20's picture
oh yes. I lose access to the
oh yes. I lose access to the net and I feel like my IQ just dropped 20 points. Resleeving in a flat has got to be the sort of thing that makes even a born-splicer feel like they've got a flu; they're slower, fuzzier, weaker, and their joints and bones ache. In zero-g, it would be even worse; their heads would be filled with fluids from poor nasal drainage, which is something that most other zero-g adapted morphs have dealt with. Add in the lack of built-in mesh access and... ouch.

"Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch. Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote." -Benjamin Franklin

DrewDavis DrewDavis's picture
"How do you meatbags live like this?"
Funnily enough I was just thinking about this today. I had a scenario running through my head of a Firewall AGI dumped behind Jovian lines for an extended mission and how HARD it would have to be to adjust to simply thinking without a cyberbrain to assist with calculations, much less limited access to the mesh. The AGI could probably still reason normally, but doing math in it's head will probably be a chore to say the least. It would have to be incredibly frustrating to someone raised in a digital enviornment. Then I decided the rest of it's team would probably tease it by asking for the answers to complex math problems and pretend they were annoyed when it couldn't find the answer right away.
Herbo Herbo's picture
I'm still young enough to be
I'm still young enough to be pliable to changes in tech, but I'm old enough to remember life before our current state of tech. Much like an Eclipse Phase ego that is able to recall life in the early years of uploading and resleeving. In [i]my case[/i], things that I now take for granted: > Not having to memorize addresses, phone numbers > Not having to coordinate meetups, plans, etc in advance, or to arrange to be home to recieve anticipated calls > Not having to rely on physical mail service as a means of communication with companies and product distributors > Not having to know someone that knows someone that actually heard/owns/saw something cool about RPGs, music, art, news, etc. > Not being able to access media from anywhere but for two or three devices, and usually only one that had any user control. > Not having to rely on physical periodicals, texts, and the f---ing Dewey Decimal System for expanding my knowledge base (or more aptly...crushing my theories to dust :-) ). > Not having to memorize which ridge was what song I wanted to hear on a record, or how thick the tape needed to be to get near to the track I wanted to hear on a casette. My children, will never have any reference frame to share my relief of burdon. At six and three+some, they won't [i]really[/i] get what life was like before WiFi, Netflix and Online Transactions. If they were tossed into a scenario where they had to use a 56k modem on a windows 3.11 machine, attend a flea-market or swap-meet as the primary means to obtain some bit of nostalgic product/collectible, or spend some time at the library answering a question that Ask.com could solve for them with a swipe of a fondle-slab...they would be as stumped as I would be trying to run program punch-cards through an old university computer. Thus, something that would be an inconvenience for me...would require a much higher expenditure of brainpower and time for them to work around because they'd have to artificially re-create a state of technological understanding that has NO rational underpinning in their world. Extrapolating this to an eclipse phase future, aside from the disorientation and inconveniences mentioned already...a transhuman flushed into a flat may not even know [i]how[/i] to go about adapting to their condition (beyond some of the things that would just biologically sort themselves out). Where would they even start? Maybe if they had spent some time training in a simulspace or downloading some skills/memories [i]beforehand[/i], they could work around it. Or if they had an older ego to help walk them through it. But a sudden >Poof< "you're a flat" scenario would be simply horrendous. Imagine waking up in the flatbed of a covered wagon in 1872? Sure you'd be able to suss a few things out, but if you didn't have anyone to help you aclimate to it, and hadn't spent some time reading up and practicing roughing it beforehand...you'd probably go the way of most people that have ever played the video game Oregon Trail "You have died of Dysentery." Stranded naked on a desert island would also be an apt comparison, I think. On the positive end of the "conversion," a transhuman may be somewhat impressed/intrigued with what other flats are capable of doing with SO much less. Much like I would be about people that not only "made do" with karosene lamps and no indoor plumbing...but seemed to enjoy their lives as much (or as little) as people in my contemporary spacetime did. No matter how far technology and civilization advance, the untamed wilderness and relative barbarism are never more than a couple generations behind us.
Shredicine Shredicine's picture
Actually
Yeah, being so used to having something and then not having it would not be an easy process. There was one time where I actually thought in my mind "Ctrl-F" to find my lost car keys.
Who are we, but slaves to our own personal interests?
yammuk yammuk's picture
I know the feeling...
About year ago I was finishing wooden sailingship model and putting some ropes on it, then I made an mistake and in the same instant I was doing with my left hand "cmd+Z".
Nebelwerfer41 Nebelwerfer41's picture
Is it even possible
Is it even possible to resleeve into a flat? There are no cortical stacks or anything to upload into, so how would it work? On a similar note, wouldn't you also have to remove the ego of the poor sucker who was born into the flat body?
thezombiekat thezombiekat's picture
Nebelwerfer41 wrote:Is it
Nebelwerfer41 wrote:
Is it even possible to resleeve into a flat? There are no cortical stacks or anything to upload into, so how would it work? On a similar note, wouldn't you also have to remove the ego of the poor sucker who was born into the flat body?
Your ego doesn’t run on your cortical stack it just keeps a backup. Your ego runs on the wetware brain. If you can call the inefficient spongy stuff in a flats scull a brain.
Nebelwerfer41 Nebelwerfer41's picture
thezombiekat wrote:
thezombiekat wrote:
Your ego doesn’t run on your cortical stack it just keeps a backup.
I understand that, but how do you get an ego into a brain without some sort of interface device. I know an egobridge can upload from a flat brain, but does it work the same in reverse? Also, the question still stands about the previous ego. Since it doesn't make any sense to create a flat in a pod, that body belongs to a zero and you have to get the old ego out somehow, right? Can you force a new ego on top of an old one?
thezombiekat thezombiekat's picture
An ego bridge incorporates a
An ego bridge incorporates a large number of nanobots that can read or write directly to the brain. The cortical stack is uninvolved in the process. When somebody uploads (for whatever reason) it is usual for these nanites to break the connections that define the ego. If you where sleaving into a flat it would usually be from somebody that had upgraded had mind wiped it on uploading, but it could be one taken by force in which case your ego would replace the previous ego as connections are moved to represent your ego. Like copying over an old cassette tape without wiping it first.
Nebelwerfer41 Nebelwerfer41's picture
Interesting, thanks for the
Interesting, thanks for the clarification.